Recently, one of my clients expressed the need to move sometime in the future from the really cute home purchased a few years ago on one of the most desirable blocks in Montclair, NJ, near everything. "I don't know if we necessarily need bigger, just a little different. Still at least 4BR, 2 BA, place for an office, ideally a finished basement, front porch, quiet street, unique style, layout (i.e. not necessarily a center hall colonial), walking to train, shops, more varied landscape... you know, the dream list."
Yes, I do know...The Dream List.
Everybody's got one, to be sure. My own website, NJDreamHouses.com, perpetuates that yearning. I, myself, invested more than a year in my own quest for a dream home. Yet in Essex County, NJ's sea of quirky older homes in towns like Montclair, Glen Ridge, Maplewood, Millburn, and South Orange, dreams aren't fulfilled as easily as they might be if one were working with an architect on plans for a brand new house or purchasing nearly-new construction.
Buyers in our area usually don't want new homes, but they bring to bear many of the collective needs for houses with this and that attractive amenity-- stylistic broad strokes easily achieved in a truly suburban home but not so easily in our 80-year-old (on average) inventory just 13 miles from the City.
For instance, central air. Maybe half the houses here now have it, but many others don't have upgraded wiring or the space required for the system without losing an attic or closets. Another current desire, for playrooms attached to kitchens so you can see your kids while you cook, renders much available inventory useless; only a $150,000 architectural fix to add one onto an home (with only an small sunroom off the living room) will do. Master bedrooms attached to luscious baths with tumbled marble walls, granite countertops, standup shower & soaking bath with jets...not likely in an average-sized home that may not even have enough closet space for today's clothes horses. Living room wall space for a 52" TV? Vaulted ceilings that coax more light into homes? People today definitely want light and bright. In the old days, homeowners were mainly concerned with warmth; fewer, smaller windows were one way to be warm.
One lovely couple I'm working with exemplify how current buyers approach the seach. The first couple of weekends, they're charged up. So much space out here! Where they're coming from -- a small NYC apartment with no furniture. The suburbs are their oyster. They realize they want something historically true to period, vintagy but not rickety. Near NYC transportation. Soon, they focus on the big yard. Quiet street. Other pretty houses on the block. Three or 4 bedrooms plus 2 more rooms for home offices, family area, and a place for grandparents to stay (preferably on a lower floor, with accessible bath). Reasonable taxes. And, of course, it has to speak to them.
The speaking to them part is the hardest part of the dream to fulfill because many houses don't even whisper a hint of what they really have to offer. They are rickety. They have bad paneling, old linoleum, mottled rugs, too-few baths, undeveloped basements with big old furnaces that look scary. I encourage a second visit, remark on hidden virtues, bring in experts to suggest design opportunities, put costs of improvements in perspective, but if a house doesn't shout out its charms, it's not going to be the one.
Still, as one client emailed me the other day: "It's funny, I feel like you're our psychologist realtor." Indeed, as I may have previously mentioned in these pages, the job is 60-90 percent psychology/10-40 percent other, depending on the nature of the deal.
Luckily my mom was a pysychologist so I have a genetic predisposition toward dispensing house-and-home therapy. It's a value-added part of my job and one of the most rewarding when minds are expanded, ideas are exchanged, fears are overcome and contracts are signed. So, when people kvetch about Realtors in online forums or at dinner parties and trot out the 'what do they really do' question, just know that what we really do, aside from knowing inventory and connecting it to the right buyers; negotiating the deal and keeping it together til closing -- is to take good people by the hand and understand and interpret what they want and convert it into what they need to live satisfyingly in one of America's great counties.